 | Chapter Summary
Chapter 17: The Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment: Intellectual Transformations
The modern secular tradition initiated
by the Renaissance was advanced by the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment.
This chapter surveys the major thinkers and ideas of these ages and discusses
the principles of the modern outlook to which they contributed.
Combining Ptolemeic astronomy, Aristotelian philosophy,
and Christian theology, medieval thought posited a hierarchical, geocentric
universe. Renaissance humanists and artists began to challenge this view
by reviving classical learning and by promoting accurate mathematical representation
of the physical world. Inspired by ancient scientific texts, the seventeenth-century
scientific thinkers gradually replaced the old Ptolemeic-Aristotelian model
of the universe with a Pythagorean-Platonic model. Copernicus took the first
steps in this effort when he challenged the cumbersome Ptolemeic system with
his Platonic heliocentric theory. Proposing the uniformity of nature, Galileo
grounded Copernicus' theory in careful observations of planets, moons, and
stars. Galileo also challenged Aristotelian physics through pioneering experiments
with motion. In an effort to separate science from faith, Galileo attacked
uncritical acceptance of ancient authority, an attack that prompted the church
to denounce his ideas and silence him. Further supporting Copernicus' theory,
Kepler's laws fused Pythagorean and Platonic principles into a mathematically
harmonious account of planetary motion. Answering the questions Kepler could
not, Newton developed a physics that explained mathematically all the phenomena
of motion within the heliocentric system. Newton also pioneered the modern
science of optics and promoted experimental technique, all while arguing that
God was the architect of the mechanical universe.
As this new model of the universe evolved,
a new approach to scientific inquiry emerged. Denying the traditional philosophical
authorities, Bacon advocated the inductive approach, arguing that conclusions
should be based on observable facts alone. Descartes promoted the deductive
approach, proclaiming the mind's ability to formulate incontrovertible first
principles from which further knowledge may be derived. These complementary
approaches to rational investigation provided crucial intellectual tools to
modern experimental and theoretical science.
The Scientific Revolution erected the
modern conception of a homogenous universe, the structure of which could be
represented in terms of mathematical relationships and chemical compositions.
Although the pioneers of this view saw no conflict between it and Christianity,
that view prompted spiritual anxiety in later centuries, anguish poignantly
articulated by Pascal. Still, the Scientific Revolution and the critical
spirit it fostered weakened traditional Christianity and all the concepts
of authority that attended it, laying the groundwork for the Enlightenment.
What the Scientific Revolution did for
the physical world, the Enlightenment strove to do for society and politics.
Cultivating Cartesian skepticism, the philosophes questioned all received
ideas, working thereby to liberate humanity from tyranny and superstition.
Many of the basic terms and concepts of this movement came from the work of
Hobbes and Locke. From Hobbes' secular political theory, the philosophes
took the rejection of divine monarchy, while rejecting its pessimism and approval
of absolutism. From Locke, the philosophes borrowed political ideas including
natural rights and constitutional government, and the epistemological notion
that knowledge comes not from innate ideas, but accumulated experience.
On this foundation, the philosophes
built a systematic critique of Western thought and belief. Denouncing traditional
Christianity as brutal and superstitious, the philosophes subjected the Bible
to critical scrutiny and rejected the clerical establishment. Most embraced
rational deism, promoting morality over ritual and freedom of conscience over
coerced observance. In the face of censorship, philosophes including Montesqieu,
Voltaire, and Rousseau advanced modern political ideas such as governmental
checks and balances, the rule of law, and government by general will. Rejecting
mercantilism, Smith proposed an enlightened economics in which governments
allow the invisible hand of the marketplace to work unimpeded. Assuming the
essential goodness of human nature, Rousseau developed an educational philosophy
that treated children as children, and many Enlightenment thinkers—including
Beccaria, Paine, and Franklin—denounced torture, war, and the slave trade.
Although most philosophes considered women inferior to men, their ideas contained
the possibility of women's equality, a possibility Wolstonecraft hoped to
realize through her critique of women's subordination. Finally, Enlightenment
optimism and veneration of science prompted the idea of continuous human progress
articulated most fully by Condorcet.
The modern outlook owes its core principles
to the Enlightenment thinkers. Borrowing the insights and methods of the
Scientific Revolution, the philosophes offered a rational, secular interpretation
of society that advocated tolerance, freedom, equality, and rule of law.
These ideals came to serve as the theoretical foundation of modern liberal
government and market economics.
|