 | Chapter Summary
Chapter 12: The Late Middle Ages: Crisis, Continuity, and Change
The Late Middle Ages (1300-1450) saw the decline
of medieval civilization. This chapter discusses the economic, political,
social, and spiritual crises that afflicted Europe during this period. The
chapter also examines the intellectual and artistic currents that developed
in this climate of upheaval. By the end of the period, the seeds of a distinctly
modern outlook had been sown, seeds that would flower during the Renaissance
and continue to grow over the succeeding centuries.
Late-medieval Europe suffered the cumulative effects
of famine, disease, and warfare. As the fourteenth century opened, an agricultural
crisis developed, causing full-scale famine by 1315. In 1347, the Black Death
struck for the first time. By the end of the last outbreak, approximately
one-third of Europe's population had died. Western Europe was further torn
by the Hundred Years War between England and France. The war finally ended
when the French drove the English from virtually all of France.
Destructive as these upheavals were, nothing undermined
medieval civilization so deeply as the decline of the papacy. Conflicts with
the French monarchy culminated with the Babylonian Captivity, during which
the papacy resided in France and was forced to pursue pro-French policies.
The Great Schism further eroded papal authority as a series of opposing popes,
ruling from Avignon and Rome, struggled for control of the church. By 1418,
the work of the Conciliar Movement healed the schism, but a strengthened papacy
thwarted its larger aim of transforming the church into a constitutional system.
As the papacy fought to maintain its position, it neglected its spiritual
and moral responsibilities, prompting attacks on the concept of papal power.
These attacks came from both political critics and
the leaders of dissenting sects. Critics such as Marsilius of Padua denied
the church's temporal authority. That authority belonged to secular rulers,
who must exercise it without clerical interference. Similarly, the dissenters
John Wycliffe and Jan Hus challenged the church's temporal and spiritual authority.
Denouncing the wealth of the higher clergy, both stressed that individuals
could achieve salvation without the church by cultivating a personal relationship
with God. The church declared both leaders heretics and persecuted their
followers.
Paralleling these political and social crises were
changes in philosophical thought and artistic expression. As the papacy declined,
the scholastic synthesis of faith and reason unraveled. Philosophers such
as William of Ockham argued that reason could not prove the truth of Christian
doctrines. Those doctrines, including the existence of God, were matters
of faith alone. Belief, therefore, was the sole basis of theology and reason
the proper tool for investigating nature. Challenging as these ideas were,
their proponents did not seek to undermine faith entirely. Rather, they sought
to disentangle faith and reason, freeing both to explore their separate realms
of the spirit and nature.
Similarly, late-medieval artists did not reject
completely established themes and forms. Writers such as Catherine of Sienna
and the Pearl Poet, as well as many visual artists, examined traditional Christian
themes through familiar forms—e.g., romance, dream vision, and the techniques
of Gothic art. However, following the example of Dante, several important
authors explored new themes and ways of using established forms. Petrarch,
Chaucer, Christine de Pizan, and others developed a vernacular literature
that pushed the limits of formal convention and demonstrated fresh interest
in human talents, worldly activities, and the complexities of heterosexual
love. Further, many of these authors, again following Dante, rediscovered
classical literature, adapting its rhetoric and forms to their purposes.
Likewise, late-medieval visual artists and musicians
expanded the possibilities of their arts. Sculptors such as Claus Sluter
and the Pisanos experimented with spatial perspective and naturalistic representation
of the human form. The Limbourg Brothers included in their manuscript illuminations
realistic portraits of their patrons and detailed depictions of peasant life.
Some of the most lasting innovations came from Italian painters. The most
important of these was Giotto, whose dramatic, psychologically engaging style
would not be rivaled until the Renaissance. Similarly, late-medieval music
built upon older styles. The ars nova broadened the limits of the
ars antiqua by incorporating into liturgical music a greater rhythmic
and vocal range. Further, ars nova composers, including Guillaume
de Machaut and Francesco Landini, introduced new systems of notation and musical
analysis, and developed secular vernacular forms such as the madrigal and
caccia.
The decline of medieval civilization did not occasion
an abrupt break with the past. Medieval institutions persisted well into
the modern age. Feudalism, for example, survived into the eighteenth century
and helped shape such modern ideas as liberty, the rule of law, and representative
government. Further, Christianity continues to influence concepts of justice,
and modern thought and art could not have developed as they did without the
foundations laid by medieval philosophers and artists. However, significant
changes did occur. During this period, for instance, Europe began to outstrip
the rest of the world in the use of technology. Further, a secular modern
outlook began to emerge. Over the succeeding centuries, that outlook would
replace religious explanations of nature with scientific ones; promote the
essential equality and freedom of individuals; and uphold the independence
of human reason.
|