 | Chapter Summary
Chapter 9: The Early Medieval West: Fusion of Classical, Christian, and Germanic Traditions
As Byzantium and Islam enjoyed their
cultural peaks, Latin Christendom struggled to rise from the remains of the
Roman Empire. This chapter discusses how Europe, under the leadership of
the church, began to emerge as a distinct civilization.
With the collapse of the Roman Empire,
Greco-Roman culture and organization declined steadily. Under the new Germanic
kingdoms, towns survived, but the focus of life and economic activity shifted
to the countryside. Meanwhile, the church served as the principal integrating
institution. Under Gregory the Great, the papacy strengthened its authority,
using Roman administrative methods to govern its own lands and direct the
activities of clergy and monks. Irish and English monks took the lead in
cultivating Latin as the language of church life, preserving elements of the
classical intellectual tradition, producing illuminated manuscripts, founding
monasteries, and converting people throughout Europe. Through these means,
the church managed to offer Europeans a coherent world view and a semblance
of civilization.
The idea of a universal empire reemerged
under Charlemagne. Descended from Clovis, the first Christian Merovingian
king, Charlemagne built a Frankish empire that encompassed much of western
and central Europe. When he was crowned by Pope Leo III, his rule symbolized
the fusion of Roman and Christian universalism with the Germanic warrior tradition.
Although Charlemagne presided over the birth of a distinctive European civilization,
his large, diverse empire crumbled after his death.
In its place developed a feudal society,
in which local lords ruled in the absence of centralized authority. These
warrior-lords governed their territories according to customary law and served
as the military vassals of their superiors. Through the manorial economic
system, land-bound serfs supported these lords, who, in turn, owed them the
duty of protection. With little hope of earthly advancement, serfs tended
to focus on heavenly rewards available through the church as represented by
local priests. As wives and daughters of feudal lords, noblewomen were entirely
subservient to men, who regarded them as morally and intellectually inferior.
However, feudal ladies performed important functions in the household and
exerted full authority when their men were away at war. If such women did
not marry, they generally entered convents where they could develop their
intellectual talents and, like Hildegard of Bingen, even rise to positions
of authority.
During this period, elements of Greco-Roman
humanism survived. Transmitters including Boethius, Cassiodorus, and Isidore
of Seville worked to preserve classical learning through translation and compilation.
The last Latin scholar trained in Greek and Greek philosophy, Boethius was
especially important as the forerunner of the high-medieval philosophers who
unified faith and reason. Other transmitters, including Alcuin of York and
Einhard, helped advance the Carolingian Renaissance, during which Charlemagne
promoted Latin education for clerics and administrators and the preparation
of reliable sacred texts. Through such enterprises, this movement prepared
the ground for the Twelfth-Century Awakening.
Early medieval literature explored both
secular and sacred themes, and much of it was written in vernacular languages.
The Welsh Mabinogion compiled Celtic British mythological tales and
provided the source for the later Arthurian legends. Irish lyric poetry drew
upon classical models to explore themes of love and nature. However, the
prose epic cycles of Ulster and Leinster were entirely unique in their narration
of heroic deeds. Based on some historical events, the Old-English Beowulf
explores the Germanic heroic ethos, representing it in a somewhat Christianized
form. Christian themes appear in the work of a few authors, including the
nuns Brigid, an Irish woman who wrote devotional poems, and Hroswitha of Gandersheim,
whose dramas developed strong Christian heroines and presented the Virgin
Mary as a model of womanhood.
Early medieval art fused Celtic, Germanic,
and Greco-Roman elements, a process that culminated with the great Ottonian
works. Illuminated manuscripts, including the Lindisfarne Gospels and the
Book of Kells, include intricate designs based on ornamental Germanic and
Celtic art. The Carolingian Gospel Book of Charlemagne features a portrait
of St. Matthew based on classical models. Charlemagne's Palatine Chapel employs
the Greco-Roman centralized plan and an exterior westwork, a German invention
that became standard for medieval churches. The Ottonian abbey church of
St. Michael at Hildesheim includes a large westwork and was built according
to the basilica plan, as was most European churches. Other innovations include
a raised western choir to accommodate a crypt and bronze doors with panels
illustrating biblical stories, the figures of which anticipate the greater
realism of later medieval sculpture.
Europe was the third civilization based
on religion to emerge after Rome. Blending Christian, Germanic, and Greco-Roman
elements, Europe developed a distinct culture with the church as its central
institution and Latin Christianity its unifying world view. Though Byzantine
and Islamic civilization outstripped European during much of the Middle Ages,
Europe eventually took the lead in shaping the modern world.
|