 | Chapter Summary
Chapter 8: The Medieval East: Byzantium and Islam
After the fall of Rome, three civilizations
emerged that were based on religion. This chapter discusses two of these—Byzantium
and Islam—and their cultural contributions to Western civilization.
As barbarian invaders dismantled the western empire,
the East survived as Byzantium with Constantinople as its capital. While
trade, urban life, and learning declined in the West, Byzantium developed
a vital economy, sophisticated intellectual and artistic life, and a strong
government that supported the Eastern church. Doctrinal and administrative
differences caused the Western and Eastern churches to split in 1054, concluding
a centuries-long division between Latin and Greek Christendom. Byzantium
reached its political height under Justinian, who reconquered parts of the
old western empire. Successive attacks from a variety of peoples, including
Latin Christians, weakened Byzantium, which finally fell to the Ottoman Turks
in 1454.
Byzantium preserved important elements
of the Greco-Roman tradition. Under Justinian's direction, Byzantine scholars
collected and codified Roman law in the four-part Corpus Juris Civilis.
Influenced by Greek historians, Byzantines including Procopius, Michael Psellus,
and Anna Comnena offered rational, coherent, if not always objective, accounts
of historical events. Byzantine religious thinkers studied Greek philosophy
but subordinated philosophical activity to the enterprise of theology.
Byzantium developed a rich musical,
artistic, and architectural tradition. Drawing from Greco-Roman and Hebrew
theory and practice, Byzantine musicians created a tonal system that influenced
the course of Western music, and Kontakion hymnody derived from early
Christian models. Byzantine art mainly concerned itself with glorifying the
empire and serving religious purposes. The iconoclastic controversy forced
artists to find new ways of approaching the problem of representing the human
form, but even so, Byzantine artists never explored realism as deeply as their
Western counterparts did. Ravenna became the center of much early artistic
activity. Buildings such as Galla Placidia's mausoleum, Theodoric's church
of Saint Apollinare, and San Vitale represent variations on both the basilica
and centralized plans and include notable paintings or mosaics depicting Christian
themes. San Vitale also includes mosaics glorifying Justinian and Theodora,
and Saint Apollinare in Classe contains an important representation of Christ
Pantocrator. The greatest Byzantine monument is Justinian's reconstructed
Hagia Sophia, a unique blend of the basilica and centralized styles that Ottoman
conquerors transformed into a mosque.
As Byzantium flourished, Islam emerged
from the Arabia. Based on the religious experience of the prophet Muhammad,
Islam grew in opposition to earlier Arab polytheism and to Judaism and Christianity.
After a period of persecution, Muhammad and his followers conquered Arabia
with the help of Bedouin converts. After Muhammad's death, the newly unified
Muslim Arabs launched a jihad, ultimately conquering an empire that
stretched from Spain to India. Integrated many cultural traditions, Muslim
civilization reached its height under the Abbasid caliphs who ruled from Baghdad.
Waves of invaders from Central Asia weakened the Arab empire until it fell
to the Ottoman Turks, whose armies pushed far into Eastern Europe.
A monotheistic religion, Islam presented
itself as the fulfillment of Judaism and Christianity. Though not considered
divine, Muhammad was regarded as the last, greatest prophet in a line that
included Abraham and Jesus. His teachings on the Five Pillars of the faith
and on a variety of practical questions are compiled in the Qur'an and Hadith.
Islam eventually broke into three majors sects: the Sunnites and Shi'ites,
who divided over questions of leadership and orthodoxy, and the Sufis, who
rejected rational speculation and instead cultivated mystical spiritual experience.
Sufism grew dramatically during the thirteenth-century Mongol invasions, as
Muslims sought solace in the face of disaster. The Islamic state was theocratic,
in which rulers governed according to religious law. Although the lot of
Arab women improved with Islam, ambiguities in the Qur'an and Hadith led to
the establishment of an Arab-style patriarchy in which women were entirely
subordinate to men. Islam accorded special status to Christians and Jews.
Although they endured restrictions and penalties as non-Muslims, these "Peoples
of the Book" generally lived free of persecution.
Islamic thought also preserved the Hellenic
tradition and helped pass it on to the West. Muslim physicians, scientists,
and mathematicians built upon the work of the Greeks, expanding their insights
and often correcting their mistakes. Islamic philosophers used Platonic and
Aristotelian ideas to explore Muslim theological concerns. Thinkers including
Al-Farabi and Avicenna used Neoplatonic and Aristotelian concepts to prove
the existence of God, while Averroës employed Aristotle to argue that philosophy
and study of the Qur'an were compatible. Ibn Khaldun contributed to historiography
with his Universal History, which includes, along with a comprehensive
account of civilization, an analytical autobiography.
Islamic literature and art displays
a wide range of forms and thematic concerns. The poet Ibn Hazm wrote a critical
analysis of love. Omar Khayyam's quatrains infused expressions of love with
philosophical resignation, while Rumi explored Sufi mystical experience.
The popular Thousand and One Arabian Nights incorporated diverse tales
within a unified frame story, employing hyperbole to evade the Muslim ban
on fiction. Working within the ban on images of living creatures, Islamic
art emphasized abstract ornamental styles. During the Umayyad and Abbasid
dynasties, distinctive architectural styles emerged. Based on Byzantine models,
shrines such as the Dome of the Rock employed calligraphy to decorate the
interiors and convey sacred messages. A standard mosque plan also developed,
focusing attention on the Qibla wall and later incorporating minarets
for muezzin calls. Among the most notable mosques are those of Damascus,
Samarra, and Cordoba. An important late work is the Alhambra, a palace-complex
in Granada designed inside to create ethereal effects conducive to reflection.
Byzantine and Islamic civilization gave
crucial legacies to the West. Byzantine Orthodoxy shaped the religious traditions
of much of Slavic Europe, and both civilizations helped to preserve and transmit
important elements of the Hellenic tradition: Byzantium, the Roman legal tradition
and modified Hellenic architectural styles; Islam, the scientific and philosophical
tradition of Greece. Contact with both civilizations enabled Latin Christendom
to absorb the Hellenic legacy during the Middle Ages.
|