 | Chapter Summary
Chapter 3: Hellenic Civilization I: From Myth to Reason
In addition to Hebrew ethical monotheism, Greek
thought is the principal source of the Western tradition. Through discussions
of Hellenic history, literature, religion, and philosophy, this chapter examines
how Greek culture moved from myth-making to systematic, self-conscious rational
thought.
Greek civilization grew from Minoan and Mycenean
culture. The Minoans of Crete were peaceful people whose arts and crafts
influenced those of their Mycenean contemporaries. On the Greek mainland,
the Myceneans developed a warrior society based on honor. Though a 300-year
Dark Age followed the fall of Mycenean civilization, its art, crafts, and
values exerted a powerful influence on later Greek culture.
After the Dark Age, the Greek polis began to take
shape, achieving its highest development in Athens. These small city-states
emerged in Greece and the regions colonized by Greeks. Based on the idea
free citizenship, the polis was governed directly by its free adult males
who believed that laws came not from gods or divine kings but from themselves.
The armed garrison state of Sparta, built upon a strict hierarchy of free
warriors and helots, pointed one direction the polis could take. However,
Athenian democracy proved the more influential direction. Through the efforts
of Solon and Cleisthenes, Athens reduced aristocratic power, opening government
to all free male citizens, who, in theory, served from a spirit of civic duty.
This system reached its height under Pericles. Not without flaws, Athenian
democracy rested on the backs of slaves, and while Sparta granted women power
to manage the household, Athens excluded women from all public life, regarding
them as minors who were legally their fathers' or husbands' wards.
Increasingly expansionistic, Athens clashed with
Sparta in the Peloponnesian War. Athens and her allies ultimately lost the
war, after which the city-states degenerated into civil strife and internecine
warfare. Severely weakened, the city-states finally fell under the dominion
of Macedon.
This history is marked by important developments
in literature and religion. Set during the mythic Mycenean past, Homer's
Iliad and Odyssey explore dimensions of human personality and
themes of pride, justice, and universal order that later thinkers would treat
more systematically. In Theogony and Works and Days, Hesiod,
like Homer, examined ideas of justice and universal order. He also considered
the origin of the universe and of good and evil, issues later thinkers would
examine through rational thought. Both poets explored their themes in terms
of the myths and deities of Olympian religion. Succeeding earlier chthonic
cults, this religion gained broad appeal throughout Greece. Lacking fixed
dogmas and priestly classes, Olympianism, with its all-too-human gods, also
lacked moral standards by which people could live their lives. In response,
some Greeks gradually reimagined Zeus as arbiter of morality and justice.
Others turned to the Eleusinian and Orphic mysteries. Founded upon myths
of death and rebirth, these cults emphasized ritual purification and emotional
experience, offering adherents the promise of eternal life that Olympianism
didn't.
Such mythopoeic thought gradually gave way to speculative
philosophy. Although philosophy never supplanted religion entirely, it enabled
many thinkers to move beyond mythic explanations of the universe and arrive
at ones based on self-conscious rational methods of inquiry. The early Cosmologists,
such as Thales, Pythagoras, and Democritus, developed rational accounts of
nature in terms of imperishable substances, mathematical principles, or the
properties of atoms. Similarly, Hippocrates and his followers rejected mythic-religious
explanations of disease and observed symptoms in order to identify their natural
causes. Against the Cosmologists, the Sophists argued that speculation about
the universe was futile. Instead, these thinkers scrutinized people and society
and instructed men in the skills of citizenship. Protagoras and other Sophists
examined questions of ethics, law, and morality, but they were philosophical
relativists whose critical method undermined traditional authority.
Greek philosophy reached its height in the Athenian
thinkers Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. Unlike the Sophists, these philosophers
shared the view that universal principles do exist and that those are available
to the rational mind. Socrates sought to discover those principles through
rigorous dialectical discussion that forced his students to participate in
the process of acquiring wisdom. Though he sought to train morally self-aware
minds, his challenging method gained him enemies who ultimately prosecuted
him and forced him to commit suicide. Plato located universal principles,
which he called Ideas or Forms, in a higher realm of true Being. The goal
of philosophy, he argued, is to train the mind to perceive these Forms and
the eternal truth they contain. Plato also built a theory of the just state
on universal principles. Since only the best-trained minds can grasp these
principles, only a philosophical elite, appropriately educated, can rule with
true wisdom and moderation. Aristotle synthesized the concept of universal
principles he inherited from Socrates and Plato with the Cosmologists' attention
to natural phenomena. He applied this synthesis to both ethics and politics.
In both areas, by considering specific problems and examples, he offered a
realistic assessment of human nature and practical guidelines for how people
could make moral decisions and live happily in well-governed communities.
In laying the groundwork of Western thought, Greek
thinkers established the principle of the autonomy of reason. They also developed
the subfields of philosophy, posed enduring questions, and pioneered the methods
of scientific inquiry. Further, they shaped the course of Christianity by
providing the terminology and techniques Christian thinkers used to develop
a systematic theology. Although these theologians argued that reason was
subject to God's revelation, confidence in reason's power never fully disappeared,
and it ultimately reasserted its autonomy in the modern world.
|