 |
|  |  |  |  | A History of World Societies, Fifth Edition
John P. McKay, Bennett D. Hill, John Buckler
|  |  |
 |  |
History WIRED
|
Chapter 31: The Age of Anxiety in the West
As Chapter 29 explained, World War I marked a "great break"
in world history. The conflict severely reduced the power and resolve
of the Western world. The German, Russian, and Austro-Hungarian empires
disappeared, Britain went from the world's leading creditor nation
to a debtor, and fighting on the Western Front destroyed much of French
industry. Chapter 30 traced the developments of powerful nationalist
movements in Asia in response to World War I that challenged Western predominance
in global affairs. This chapter explores the crisis in confidence
that the war provoked within the West. The sheer destructiveness
of the war challenged widespread beliefs in the superiority of Western
culture and political traditions. Increasingly Westerners questioned
long-held beliefs about government, class, industrialism, and capitalism.
Western art reflected this anxiety. During the 1920s
and 1930s Western societies struggled to deal with these frustrations and
to recreate a sense of stability and security that the war had shattered.
Chapter 32 will examine why and how these efforts failed. The following Internet
exercises will explore the anxieties between World War I and World War
II and how Westerners dealt with them.
Helpful Hints:
- You may want to begin by printing this page. As you explore different sites, use the printout to refer back to the instructions and questions detailed in each activity.
- On many web sites you can increase the size of the images by clicking on them. Whenever possible, use the larger images to examine fine details in photographs.
Activity One:
-
To many Westerners, the end of the war
promised a return to happier times. They clung to nineteenth-century
values of "progress, reason, and the rights of the individual" (McKay,
A
History of World Societies [Fifth Edition], p. 985). Others were
less optimistic. Read the excepts at Modern
History Sourcebook: Oswald Spengler: The Decline of The West, 1922
and Modern History
Sourcebook: Paul Valéry: On European Civilization and the European
Mind, c. 1919, 1922. (You've read part of Valéry's thoughts
on page 985 of McKay, A History of World Societies [Fifth Edition].)
Both men claim that World War I marked
the passing of an era. How do they depict the past era? Describe
their predictions for the new order, and analyze how they use history
to defend their claims. Why did they believe that the war had
ushered in a new era?
Activity Two:
-
This same skepticism toward nineteenth-century values
can be seen in the art of the early twentieth century.
Go to Web
Museum: Expressionism, Web
Museum: Picasso and Cubism, Web
Museum: Toward Abstraction, and History
of Surrealism. (Be sure to carefully read the text and study
the images provided. Click on at least one of the artist names
that are hyperlinked at each of these sites.) Explain how artistic
expression was changing in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Against what styles and traditions were artists rebelling? What new
styles and traditions were emerging?
-
You can also observe similar
trends in the world of music. Go to Classical
Midi Archives: Stravinsky and listen to the passages from The
Rite of Spring. Analyze how this work reflects the new expressiveness
of the art world. World War I furthered these trends.
-
For more
here, read the text and study the images at World
War I and the Art World. (Be sure to place the cursor over the
topics on the left-hand side of the screen and click all the links.)
Describe the impact of the war on artistic expression. Did it lead
to radical departures in the art world, or did it encourage contemporary
trends in the art world? Now go to The
Metropolitan Museum Special Exhibitions: Painters in Paris, 1895-1950.
At the bottom of the page, click "Learn more about this exhibition" and
read the text. Be sure to visit the hyperlinks at the bottom of this
page.
-
Return to The
Metropolitan Museum Special Exhibitions: Painters in Paris, 1895-1950.
Click on "View images from this exhibition," and analyze these images.
Identify paintings that, in your opinion, exemplify the various schools
of modern art emerging in the early twentieth century - expressionism,
cubism, abstraction, and surrealism. Try to find one painting that
fits in each category, and justify your decision in a brief paragraph.
Finally, analyze how these new forms of art challenged nineteenth-century
values of progress and reason.
Activity Three:
-
The revolution in the art and music world
failed to inspire rapt attention among much of the middle and working classes
in the West. Developments in art remained the interest of a distinct
minority. The general public instead fell in love with two new mediums
of entertainment - movies and the radio. For a history of the early
era of motion pictures, go to .movie.site, and
read the sections "The Birth of Film," "The Silent Era," and "The Beginning
of the Studio System."
-
Explain the evolution of motion pictures during
this time period. What kinds of motion pictures appealed to broad
audiences? How did the industry that produced motion pictures evolve?
Did producers of motion pictures view their craft as artistic expression
or entertainment? McKay, A History of World Societies (Fifth Edition), p. 994,
states that "the greatest appeal
of motion pictures was that they offered ordinary people a temporary escape
from the hard realities of international tensions, uncertainty, unemployment,
and personal frustrations." For more information on postwar life, see
Activity Four.
-
Go to Selected
Film Clips of Rudolph Valentino, Buster
Keaton: The Man Who Fell to Earth, and The
Photos of Gloria Swanson. Read the texts, study the images, and
watch the film clips where appropriate when visiting these sites.
All three of these movie stars were incredibly popular box office draws
during the 1920s. Describe the kinds of films they made. Why
do you believe these genres had such a broad appeal? Were they realistic
or fantastic? How did they allow people to escape the problems they
faced in life?
-
Radio provided a similar release. For a history
of radio, go to Old
Time Radio: The Golden Years and read the text in this detailed
timeline. Click on the hyperlinks that will allow you to listen to
songs, speeches, and excerpts from radio programing from 1918 to 1939.
Be sure to visit all links to Donna Halper's site and listen to the excerpts
there. Analyze to what extent the growth of the radio industry paralleled
the growth of the motion picture industry. For example, how did the industry that
produced radio programs evolve in this time? Why did people tune
in to the radio? Did it provide a release from everyday strains much
as movies did? What other purposes did radio have besides entertainment?
Activity Four:
-
What were the stresses and strains to
which Activity Three alludes? For insight, go to Aftermath:
When the Boys Came Home, which explores Great Britain during
the 1920s. Within this site, read A
Land Fit for Heroes and The
Lost Generation: Myth and Reality (be sure to click "continue" and read
both pages here). Also view the Gallery.
Analyze the problems society faced in postwar Britain. What were
economic conditions like? What psychological problems appeared?
What was life like for veterans of the war?
Activity Five:
- The experiences of Great Britain were
similar to those of the rest of Europe. Everywhere on the continent governments
struggled to restore peace and prosperity. For an overview
of this dilemma, see Brad DeLong's essay, Restoring
the Pre-World War I Economy. According to this economic historian,
what economic dislocations did the war cause? How did the leaders
of France, Britain, the United States, and Germany try to remedy them?
Why did their efforts fail?
Activity Six:
-
As DeLong's essay in Activity Five
explains, the prosperity before the war in the West did not return during
the 1920s except in the United States. After 1929, the Great Depression
consumed all the economies of the West, including the economy of the United States.
For the international dimension of the Great Depression, read the essay
at The
Great Depression. According to this site, how did the economic
slump that began in 1929 in the United States affect Europe? What
government policies in the West exacerbated the economic decline?
Analyze how the Great Depression challenged traditional assumptions about
the economy and government's role in creating economic growth. Summarize
your answer to this last task in a brief essay (4-5 paragraphs).
Activity Seven:
-
The depth and duration of the Great
Depression forced Western governments to respond with new and innovative
strategies. In the United States, this approach was known as the
New Deal. For an overview, go to New
Deal and read this brief essay. Describe the New Deal and its
strategy for meeting the challenges of the Great Depression. What role
did government play in the New
Deal? Who were most New Deal policies designed to help? What
traditional attitudes toward government and its role in people's lives
did the New Deal challenge?
-
To further analyze the impact of the
New Deal on America, go to Work
Progress Administration (WPA) projects in Georgia (read the essay
at the beginning of this site, and then observe images that interest you), A
New Deal for the Arts (read the essays and study the images at all
the hyperlinks here), and Social
Security History (read to the section "Atlantic Charter"). These
web sites examine two very popular programs in the New Deal - the Work
Projects Administration (which included federal employment of artists)
and Social Security. McKay, A History of World Societies (Fifth Edition), p.1001,
states that the New Deal "marked
a profound shift from the traditional stress on family support and community
responsibility." Describe how both programs represented this trend.
What were the goals of each program? Who were they designed to help?
Does the federal government of the United States still engage in efforts such
as these? Why do you think the depression led to such programs?
Why are they still popular? Summarize your answers
in a brief essay.
Activity Eight:
-
The New Deal signaled a clear break
from traditional nineteenth-century ideas on economic thought and the role
of government. Democratic governments in the West demonstrated similar
trends. Many academics and philosophers encouraged Governments
to assume broader responsibilities during the 1930s. No scholar had
more influence during this time period than John Maynard Keynes, a British
economist; for his impact, go to The
Keynesian Revolution. Analyze how Keynes challenged traditional
assumptions about economic growth and the role of the government in the
economy. Why, according to
Keynes, was the Great Depression so enduring? What role did he believe
that government should play in restoring economic growth? Overall,
what role did he urge governments to play in the economy? What older
assumptions did he challenge? For example, how did he view balanced
budgets, government spending, and interest rates?
|
|  |  |
|