1. What Is Globalization?
Globalization means many different things to
students depending on their experiences. International students are usually
well aware of the power of multinational corporations, the size of the U.S.
market, and the opportunities and constraints on access to global markets.
Students from the United States have an image of globalization that will depend
on whether they have seen jobs lost to international competitors, been part
of firms that have increased exports or imports, or read carefully the country
of origin information on products they purchase.
Teaching strategy: Ask
students how they have experienced the effects of globalization. Most students
will be able to name imported products they purchase. Some will not know that
well-known foreign companies like Toyota and BMW produce products in the United
States. Often students are unaware of the fact that many U.S. brand names
are owned by companies with headquarters outside the country. Many students
will be unaware of U.S. leadership in international trade of services, financial
assets, and technology.
-
Globalization is neither new nor widespread.
Ask students if they ever read National
Geographic articles about the treasures found on ancient sunken ships.
These articles often describe ships containing products from many different
areas of the region, as traders sought out and brought new products to new
customers. Though globalization is not new, not all countries participate
in global markets. Ask students to name the countries banned for U.S. travelers
(Cuba and North Korea, and until June 2004, Libya.)
-
The role of technological change
Three technological factors are contributing
to the spread of globalization: falling transportation costs, improved communications,
and computers.
Teaching strategy: Ask
students if they have used voice over Internet protocol (VOIP) for international
telephone calls. Have they corresponded with friends while either they or
the friend was in another country? Have they called a companys customer
assistance and spoken with someone in another country? This last question
may create controversy among students fearing the loss of jobs to overseas
competitors.
-
Measuring globalization
Foreign Policy magazine uses a four-category system to
rank countries on degree of globalization. These categories are political
engagement, technology, personal contact (travel and tourism, international
communications, and cross-border income transfers), and economic integration.
2. Globalization controversy
-
Arguments against globalization
Opponents of globalization argue it does more
harm than good. Critics view globalization as primarily enriching corporate
elite. Their view is multinational corporations enrich themselves at the expense
of poor people and the environment, using international organizations to promote
their interests.
Developing countries are pitted against each
other, with the lowest-cost producer, often ignoring social and environmental
costs, racing to the bottom to get the jobs and income offered.
Workers rights and child labor rules are often ignored.
The WTO, IMF, and World Bank are seen as agents
supporting the interests of multinational corporations and industrialized
countries.
-
Arguments in favor of globalization
Supporters of globalization argue trade raises
the standard of people living of both industrialized and developing countries.
Supporters point out that the major international organizations are sponsored
and led by governments not corporations. Advocates also contend that the race
to the bottom is not documented, and multinational corporations are
motivated by market opportunities, not lax environmental enforcement.
Supporters of globalization contend it expands
opportunities, improves working standards, and raises wages of workers.
Teaching strategy: Use
local examples to demonstrate the impact of globalization. Have students read
the country of origin labels on their clothes before class. Bring a world
map to show students where their clothing comes from. Ask students if they
would be willing to pay more for clothing made in the United States.
3. Globalization, Economic Growth, and Incomes
The Asian tigersHong Kong, Korea, Singapore,
and Taiwanare often used as the example of globalization leading to
economic growth. Todays students do not remember when Japan, the model
for the Asian tigers, was considered a low-cost, low-quality producer.
Teaching strategy: Have
students consider the following questions:
-
Have those countries that pursued globalization
grown faster than those that did not?
-
Has income inequality increased or decreased
in countries pursuing globalization?
-
Has the gap between rich and poor countries
decreased with globalization?
-
Has poverty been reduced in countries
pursuing globalization?
4. Financial Crises and Globalization
-
Crises of the 1990s
During
the 1990s, financial crises occurred in Mexico and Southeast Asia in countries
pursuing economic growth through globalization. Data provided in the text
show all of the countries except Malaysia had short-term debt greater than
the international currency reserves in the country. Except for Mexico, each
country had a high percentage of bank loans relative to the countrys
GDP. In each country, the stock market had dropped dramatically, and during
the financial crises, each countrys currency dropped significantly
against the U.S. dollar.
-
Exchange rates and financial crises
Each of the countries had a fixed exchange rate
policy prior to the crisis period. If a financial crisis does not occur, fixed
exchange rates reduce currency risk facilitating trade. To maintain a fixed
exchange rate the government must intervene, buying or selling its currency
to maintain equilibrium. In the case of Mexico, given the long history of
financial crises coinciding with presidential elections (every six years),
Mexican and other investors sold peso assets and bought dollar assets, betting
the peso would need to be devalued. The central bank, not having sufficient
reserves to absorb the increased supply of pesos, eventually had to devalue
the peso. Similar scenarios occurred in the Southeast Asian countries and
in the process many businesses failed, having borrowed in dollars or other
world currencies and now being unable to repay loans with lower-valued domestic
currencies.
-
What caused the crises?
Four
factors contributed to the crises:
-
Falling international reserves
-
Lack of transparency
-
Short-term international investment
If the countries had not pursued globalization,
they could have avoided the financial crises, but protectionism limits choices
for consumers, reduces competition, and reduces market opportunities for entrepreneurs.